Reporting of Just Culture
|1.1 Contact organisation||EUROCONTROL: The European organisation for the safety of air navigation.|
|1.2 Contact organisation unit||Directorate Single Sky - Performance Review Unit (DSS/PRU)|
|1.3 Contact name||Performance Review Unit - EUROCONTROL|
|1.5 Contact mail address||96 Rue de la Fusée|
|1.6 Contact e-mail address||NSA-PRU-Support@eurocontrol.int|
|1.7 Contact phone number||+32 2 729 39 56|
|2. Metadata update|
|2.1. Metadata last certified||not applicable|
|2.2. Metadata last update||01 November 2016|
3. Statistical presentation
3.1. Data description
ref. EASA Annex to ED Decision 2014/035/R
Just Culture means a culture in which front line operators or others are not punished for actions, omissions or decisions taken by them that are commensurate with their experience and training, but where gross negligence, willful violations and destructive acts are not tolerated.
A detailed description of the indicator and data requirements are available from the EASA Acceptable Means of Compliance and Guidance Material (EASA AMC/GM).
Just Culture is studied for the first time at European level.
The PRB and EASA acknowledge that the JC definition provided in EU IR691/2010 is just one of the available definitions of JC.
3.2. Classification system
The JC indicator is determined at State and ANSP level.
The areas surveyed in the questionnaire are:
- policy and its implementation,
- legal/judiciary, and occurrence reporting; and,
- and investigation.
The questions are answered with "yes" or "no" in order to reveal obstacles and impediments in each of the three areas.
3.3. Sector coverage
The measures pertain to the Air Transport and Air Traffic Management Sector of the economy.
3.4. Statistical concepts and definitions
The metrics are based on two questionnaires (State and ANSP level) published in the EASA AMC/GM documents.
|Policy and its implementation||Legal/judiciary||Occurrence reporting and investigation|
|State level Questionnaire||9 questions||7 questions||2 questions|
|ANSP level questionnaire||13 questions||3 questions||8 questions|
For each answer justification and evidence should be provided in order to better understand and assess possible obstacles and impediments to the application of JC.
Additionally to the questionnaires, States and ANSPs may report on Just Culture using the following formats:
- GM13 SKPI - Just culture - Reporting and Verification at State level; and,
- GM14 SKPI - Just culture - Reporting and Verification at ANSP level.
It is expected that each certified provider completes the ANSP JC questionnaire, with exception of those who avail all the air navigation services to other certified ANSPs in accordance with Article 10 of (EC) 550/2004.
NSAs are required to gather information on JC from appropriate entities in the State (e.g. Minister of Transport, Justice Department) to complete the State questionnaire.
3.5. Statistical unit
The statistical units are States and ANSPs.
3.6. Statistical population
The statistical population comprises the States and ANSPs in the Single European Sky Area.
3.7. Reference area
The reference area is the Single European Sky Area.
3.8. Time coverage
2012 is the first year for which data is presented (available in 2013).
3.9. Base period
4. Unit of measure
Answers provided by the States/ ANSPs.
5. Reference period
- The first reference period (RP1) covers the calendar years 2012 to 2014 inclusive.
- The second reference period (RP2) covers the calendar years 2015 to 2019 inclusive.
Unless decided otherwise, the following reference periods shall be of five calendar years.
6. Institutional Mandate
Provisions are established in:
- Single Sky Framework Regulation (EC) 549/2004;
- Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 390/2013;
- Performance Regulation (691/2010);
- EASA Basic Regulation (EC) No 216/2008;
- EASA Standardisation Inspection (EU) 736/2006; and,
- EASA AMC/GM for Safety KPIs, issued by EASA in coordination with PRB.
- The information is disseminated in accordance with Article 21 of the Performance Regulation (691/2010).
- The information is disseminated in accordance with Article 22 of Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 390/2013.
8. Release policy
8.1. Release calendar
Typically information is released annually in in June of the following year.
8.2. Release calendar access
8.3. User access
Information is disseminated to the general public via the EUROCONTROL website.
9. Frequency of dissemination
Information is disseminated on a yearly basis as soon as the data is verified.
10. Dissemination format
The information is available on the EUROCONTROL website.
11. Accessibility of documentation
Documentation on methodology is available at EASA Acceptable means of compliance and guidance material.
12. Quality Management
The legal framework for quality management is established by EU legislation.
12.1. Quality assurance
EASA verifies both NSAs and ANSPs questionnaires through desktop audits. The PRB is involved in some EASA verifications through temporary participation of PRU staff.
For each State, EASA verifies the State's questionnaire, the questionnaire completed by the largest ANSP and one additional ANSP randomly chosen.
The quality assurance includes, inter alia, the following processes:
- verification of the legal references using the national gazette website,
- cross-check with data available in external sources (e.g. the Network Manager and/or EUROCONTROL),
- cross-check with information published in States's or ANSP's website.
Further, EASA will conduct a verification on the qualitative analyses which have been submitted by States and ANSPs through the tables contained in AMC 9 SKPI and AMC 10 SKPI.
12.2. Quality assessment
The NSAs are responsible to verify the questionnaires completed by ANSPs and to report results of the verification to EASA. There are at least two types of NSA organisation for verifying the questionnaires: either there is a specific organisation or the existing oversight organisation is used to verify the questionnaire. The uniformity of NSA verification output across Europe is maintained through:
- the AMC/GM material published by EASA;
- the FAQ EASA web-page;
- the EASA helpdesk; and,
- the organisation of workshops and/or bilateral meetings.
The information is published for performance monitoring purposes in accordance with the relevant EU legislation.
The data is collected for the entire Single European Sky Area.
14. Accuracy and reliability
14.1. Overall accuracy
The accuracy of the indicator can be influenced by the the NSAs and ANSPs interpretation of the survey questions.
While the JC indicator helps identifying obstacles to impediments to the application of JC, it does not provide an indication of the magnitude of those obstacles. The complementary qualitative analysis of the evidence and justifications provided by States and ANSPs is therefore an important element of the overall assessment.
15. Timeliness and punctuality
The data refer to the status of JC which was measured the year before its publication.
The data is updated by ANSPs and NSAs at least once per year. The data is then verified by EASA in March of the following year.
Data are comparable being measured in the same way across European Member States. However, benchmarking is not allowed in safety.
16.1. Comparability — geographical
Geographical comparability is valid.
16.2. Comparability over time
Comparability over time is valid.
17.1. Coherence — cross domain
17.2. Coherence — internal
The data is assumed to be internally coherent as provided.
18. Cost and burden
19. Data revision
Data could change with time due to two reasons:
- to reflect a change in managing JC within a State or an ANSP ,
- to reflect an improved verification.
20. Statistical processing
20.1. Source data
Questionnaires and forms completed by States and ANSPs (see also Statistical concepts and definitions).
The completed tables included in AMC 9 and 10 (optional).
20.2. Frequency of data collection
After the first completion, ANSPs and NSAs are requested to update the questionnaires on a yearly basis.
20.3. Data collection
The State and ANSP questionnaires are collected by EASA though a web application.
20.4. Data validation
EASA verifies the updated questionnaires by March of the following year at the latest. After EASA verification, the data described are sent to the PRB by March of the following year at the latest.
The data validation is done as follows:
- During the desktop verification, the consistency between the answer (yes or no), the justifications provided and the evidence is evaluated. In a second step, the level of JC implementation is verified through external information available to EASA, NM and PRB. Clarification questions could be addressed to the NSA either via mail or telephone.
20.5. Data compilation
Following the verification by EASA, the following data is provided to the PRB:
- the States' completed questionnaires including justifications and evidence;
- the ANSP questionnaires verified by EASA, including justifications and evidence;
- the JC PI computations for each State and each ANSP; and,
- the qualitative analyses on areas of improvements provided by ANSPs, NSAs and the ones directly performed by EASA.
This data is published by the Performance Review Body (PRB) of the Single European Sky. Every effort has been made to ensure that the information and analysis contained on this website are as accurate and complete as possible. Despite these precautions, should you find any errors or inconsistencies we would be grateful if you could please bring them to the Performance Review Unit’s attention.
The information may be copied in whole or in part providing that the copyright notice and disclaimer are included. The information may not be modified without prior written permission from the PRB. The views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the official views or policy of EUROCONTROL or of the European Commission, which make no warranty, either implied or express, for the information contained on this website, neither do they assume any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of this information. The PRB reserves the right to change or amend the information provided at any time and without prior notice.
Information contained in this website is checked and updated with due diligence on a regular basis. This notwithstanding, data may become subject to changes during the intervening periods. Note that the content of this page and the information provided might change once the actual monitoring cycle starts and the first safety data is received.
The PRB does not assume any liability or guarantee for the accuracy and completeness of the information provided to the linked third-party websites. The PRC does not control the linked sites and is not responsible for the contents of any linked site or any link in a linked site, or any changes or updates to such links. The PRB provides these links to users of this website as a convenience alone.
Information provided on this page should not replace EASA Acceptable Means of Compliance and Guidance Material documents.